New Shingles or New Roof? Restoration vs Replacement

New Shingles or New Roof? Restoration vs Replacement

Deciding between a roof repair vs. replacement is challenging because it requires professional expertise. Re-roofing or roof replacements add value to your home and enhance its curb appeal. However, each option has a unique purpose, so understanding the differences between them can help you make a choice between roof restoration vs. replacement. 

Roof Replacement 

Roof replacement involves installing a new roof after removing the old one. The work is extensive but because everything is new, it’s the best way to ensure your roof will last for years to come. If your roof has issues such as discoloration, damaged shingles, leaks, mold or storm damage, a total replacement can negate your concerns and ensure you have a fully functional roof once work is complete. 

Roof Restoration 

A roof restoration consists of conducting a thorough cleaning on your roof before adding a new layer of shingles on top of the ones that are already there, the goal being to return the appearance of the roof to its original state after it’s endured damage or wear and tear. 

It’s worth noting that your roof has to meet some requirements before a restoration can be completed. Building codes prohibit a roof having more than two layers of shingles on your roof, so if a restoration has been completed previously, you’ll have to replace it with your roof instead.  

Additionally, if your roof has been restored, it’s difficult to know what the condition of the bottom layer of your shingles is. If this is a concern for you, you might want to opt for a roof repair instead, which is the best way to ensure that your roof is safe, functional and sturdy. 

When a Roofing Restoration Is Ideal 

Roof restoration may be a good choice if your roof is in relatively good condition with minimal signs of wear and tear. If your roof has extensive damage, it’s not always wise to restore instead of replacing your roof, as severe damage may affect the overall structure and integrity of your restored roof. It’s always important to contact a professional who can help you decide the ideal recommendation for your roof.  

Roof Restoration vs. Replacement – Which is Best? 

Although you may still want to choose the most cost-effective roofing solution, the most important thing you can do is assess your roof to determine whether you need a roof repair or replacement. 

Ask yourself these pertinent questions after your evaluation: 

  • Lifespan: How old is your roof? If your roof is older than 15 years, it’s usually best to think about replacement. 
  • Damages:  If your roof has withstood extensive damage, replacement might be the better option. Ask your roofer for their insight. 
  • Warranty period: If your home or your roof is under warranty, speak with the manufacturer to see what they can offer.  

Can You Reduce Costs with Roof Repairs?  

If damage is minimal, you might be considering roof repair vs. replacement or restoration. If damage is localized to a small area and leaks, mold and other issues haven’t spread, repairs can be a more cost-effective option. That said, a roof that’s aged beyond 10 to 15 years is usually a better candidate for replacement.  

Trust the Professionals at Thompson Creek With Your Roof 

At Thompson Creek, we pride ourselves in replacing roofs. Whether moving into a home that needs a new roof, or replacing the roof that has lasted you many years, we’re here to help during every step of the process. If you need a roof replacement, our team can help. Contact us today to schedule a free estimate.